Because of the seasonal and weather changes, it is natural that the temperature of the environment turns hot or cold. Thus, a lot of people buy ventilation systems to regulate temperature conditions inside the living space. Air conditioning systems are employed for summers and hot days while heating systems for cold winter days. Nonetheless, almost all of the homes and establishments today have these devices to improve living conditions.
But as decades pass by and technology continues to develop, ventilation systems have evolved and temperatures are easily controlled without using remote controls or clicking any button.
Presenting, four of the best smart thermostats in the market: respectively, Ecobee 4, Ecobee3, Nest 3, and Honeywell. This review will compare each of these devices according to its features and specs. This will also delve into reviews and comments regarding these devices. By the end of this review, you will get to decide what to buy with these premium smart thermostats that are all available currently for purchase. So today we will present the 4 best smart thermostats comparison between: Ecobee4 vs. Ecobee3 vs. Nest 3 vs. Honeywell.
Ecobee4 vs. Ecobee3 vs. Nest 3 vs. Honeywell
Last update on 2020-05-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
Table of Contents
- What are Smart Thermostats?
- #1. Ecobee4 Alexa-Enabled Thermostat with Sensor
- #2. Ecobee3 Thermostat with Sensor
- #3. Nest 3 Learning Thermostat – Easy Temperature Control for Every Room
- #4. Honeywell Lyric Round 2.0 Wi-Fi Smart Programmable Thermostat
- Similarities between Ecobee4, Ecobee3 Thermostat, Nest 3, and Lyric Round 2.0 Wi-Fi Smart Programmable Thermostat
- The Best Smart Thermostats: Ecobee4 vs. Ecobee3 vs. Nest 3 vs. Honeywell – Which One Should You Buy?
What are Smart Thermostats?
These are programmable devices that maintain and controls the temperature inside a space. Unlike a regular thermostat, these devices are much automated and do not use remote controls. Instead, the internet is used in the temperature regulation via an app that could be downloaded to Android devices such as smartphones and tablets. This means that users could adjust the temperature settings wherever they are.
Aside from temperature regulation, these thermostats are designed for reliability and efficiency. You’ll get notifications on air filters needs changing. Also, this device takes the record of the duration and the history of temperature adjustments. As compared to the typical thermostat, this has been found to be more energy saving as necessary it to be.
#1. Ecobee4 Alexa-Enabled Thermostat with Sensor
This is mainly a smart thermostat with built-in Amazon’s Alexa and sensors. This 1 lb thermostat made from plastic has an intuitive black interface with a temperature display that is readily adjusted manually through its 3.5” touchscreen display or through voice over. Nonetheless, you could easily regulate and change the temperature through calling Alexa. It brags over its far-field voice-over technology which seems to be a good idea but not really concretely implemented with this device.
This device is multi-purpose. It reads the news, adjusts temperatures, and even tells a joke. This is like Amazon’s Alexa incorporated in a smart thermostat. Aside from that, the package comes with a sensor that functions on temperature optimization. Likewise, if you need more for your other rooms, then it is available for purchase online.
The device works using an Ecobee app which could be downloaded into your mobile iOs, Apple Home Kits, and Android devices. Through this app, you could monitor and also adjust temperature settings wherever you are. Also, you’ll receive notifications upon any suspicious activity detected. This system alerts depends on the sensors you’d employ on your space.
This product has high compatibility to various ventilators including those who are gas-fired, electric, and oil. This is absolutely an efficient and easy to use thermostat for your ventilation systems. As compared to its previous version, this product has a lot of added features which makes it a total lit! You can also check out our list of the best Wi-Fi thermostats.
Specifications and Features:
• Built-in Amazon’s Alexa
• Smartphone monitoring through the EcoBee App
• Automated Temperature Adjustments
• Easy to Use and Install
• High Compatibility with Ventilation Systems
• Sophisticated Design and Portable
• Multiple Embedded Microphones
• Works with Different Smart Home Devices
#2. Ecobee3 Thermostat with Sensor
This is the predecessor of Ecobee 4 which is still good though to be utilized as a smart thermostat. Like the current model, the design and the material used for constructing the device is entirely the same. It is made from plastic and has a black coating. Though, the current model is a bit rounder than the former.
Also, like the current model, the device is made for efficiency and temperature reliability. It adjusts the temperature readily through the same Ecobee app. Likewise, through this app, you could be regularly updated with the real-time details regarding the temperature of your home. The device is easy to install and use as the present one also.
However, this model does not have the built-in voice service as the current one. Nonetheless, the device is still compatible with Amazon Echo. But it goes separately with the device itself.
Also, the device is empowered with sensors. But nonetheless, this model has limitations as compared to the current one. The package does not come also with a free sensor. Instead, you’ll need to buy a separate sensor in order to activate the temperature regulation sensor.
Overall, the device is no letdown. Some users find this better than the current brand. Integrating Alexa complicates the device much. For some, the concept was a fail and unreliable.
Specifications and Features
• Works with Amazon Echo
• Compatibility with Various Ventilation Systems
• Fast and Reliable Temperature Adjustments
• Real-time Monitoring through the App
• Sends Alerts and Notifications
• Sensors could be installed
• Energy Efficient
• Supports Apple, iOs, and Android Devices
More: Wink Hub 2 vs Smartthings – Which is the Best Smart Hub?
#3. Nest 3 Learning Thermostat – Easy Temperature Control for Every Room
The 3rd generation of Nest Thermostat is upgraded with multiple features that a lot of users love. The 1 lb circular device is mainly made of metal coming from three different textures: copper, stainless steel, and white. The construction of the device is superb. Its thin, sleek, and durable as screws are well-tightened. The interface and design are very user-friendly. The device has a bright and sharp display with a high-resolution screen for easy adjustments to temperature conditions.
This Nest’s flagship thermostat incorporates multiple modes and options enjoying the flexibility of the device. It has the “Home/Away” mode where the ventilation system will immediately turn off once it detects that nobody is present at the house. Also, the auto-schedule where you could set temperatures a week before as needed. The “Farsight” which illuminates the device’s interface once it identifies you inside the room. However, this “Farsight” feature is not too smartly. Pets who are often around the house is readily detected by the device.
This device in order to work must be connected to WiFi and must be installed in an app. The app is downloadable to any Android but not compatible with Apple-made devices. The app has good design and layout but hard to deal with. It’s much better to set the temperature to its web version.
It could be linked on with multiple sensors such as temperature, humidity, and near-field activity. But nonetheless, there are few mishaps with these sensors. Also, the device could be formatted to different languages.
As for voice-activated speakers, this device works well with Amazon Echo and Google Home. This is also highly compatible with almost all HVAC systems available in the market. This device is easy to setup and use. It is also energy efficient as needed.
Specifications and Features
• Robust and Innovative Design
• Compatible with All HVAC systems
• Works with Amazon Echo and Google Home
• Multiple Modes and Functions
• Remote control via an App or Software
• Easy setup and utilization
• Energy Efficient
• Large Screen Resolution
• Supports Different Sensors
More: Tile vs Trackr – Which is the Best Bluetooth Tracker or Smart Item Finder?
#4. Honeywell Lyric Round 2.0 Wi-Fi Smart Programmable Thermostat
An upgrade from 2014’s first generation of Lyric Round, this 1.35 lb circular disc-like with large glass display that has several touch-sensitive buttons and control wheel that rotates as needed. The temperature is displayed in the center of the thermostat written in black large texts. On the side includes menus and buttons that are used for various functions.
This intelligent device needs to be connected with an app that should be downloaded to your Android 4.2 or iOs 8.4 devices. Once installed, you’ll be presented with menus and options with friendly layout and design. Through this app, you’ll get to monitor and control temperature into your HVAC system. Also, smart alerts will be receiving via this app to indicate that the air filter needs changing or there’s someone inside your home.
It is entirely flexible to most of HVAC hardware and systems including heat pumps, single and multi-stage heating and cooling systems. This also supports voice controls specifically Amazon’s Alexa and Apple Home Kit’s Siri for a hand’s free operation. Likewise, a wireless router that connects to the internet is needed for this device to run.
Geofencing is one of the unique features that this device has. Like a built-in motion sensor that previous smart thermostats have, this device uses a phone tracking location system where you will be located. Once you’ll be detected near the room, the HVAC system will immediately turn on. Conversely, if you are out, it will turn off.
But nonetheless, this feature is one of the weaknesses of this thermostat. Privacy will be infiltrated and your current location will be easily noted. Nonetheless, it is quite unreliable because you can’t have the smartphone with you always to turn the device on. Though, the device could still be manually operated.
Another weakness that the model has is its app. It keeps on losing signal and connection is not established much with the HVAC system. Likewise, Honeywell has already updated their app to address these problems.
But other than that, the product is great. Easy to install and has a very intuitive design. It’s extremely useful for people.
Specification and Features
• Supports Amazon Alexa and Apple’s Home Kit
• Smart Temperature Adjustment
• Compatible with Android, OS, and Mac Devices
• Good Thermostat Design
• Multiple Modes
• Easy to Use and Setup
• Energy Efficient
Similarities between Ecobee4, Ecobee3 Thermostat, Nest 3, and Lyric Round 2.0 Wi-Fi Smart Programmable Thermostat
In general, all products presented are recommendable. These products won’t be named as ‘best’ without a due reason. These products have been bought by a lot of customers and had gained numerous positive feedbacks coming from them. However, just like any product, they have similarities and differences on which you should take note on.
As stated, these products adjust temperature intelligently. It uses an app or software in order to monitor and regulate the temperature inside the space. Aside from regulation, the app sends notifications and smart alerts to indicate problems or issues to the system. Also, all devices listed are cloud dependent relying on the Internet in order to run.
All devices also work well with a smart voice control such as the Amazon’s Alexa or Apple Home Kit’s Siri. These devices also support smart home devices such as lights and locks. Though, there is still a variation with its inclusivity.
It is also proven that these devices are easy to setup and energy efficient. Their designs are very different but all are intuitive and very sophisticated. Any of these devices you will choose on buying would really not matter that much since all have amazing features.
The Best Smart Thermostats: Ecobee4 vs. Ecobee3 vs. Nest 3 vs. Honeywell – Which One Should You Buy?
What Smart Thermostat Works For Me?
Basically, the answer to this question depends on your convenience and likes. All of these products are constructed and designed differently. Though all have some similar features, they have few features that one lacks from the other.
For starters, let’s look at reliability.
For this, let’s give the bat to Nest 3. Why?
Unlike any other products listed here, Nest 3 is more flexible with useable features. The device is more compatible with almost all HVAC hardware and systems. Though it won’t work with Apple’s Home Kit, this device has highly responsive sensors and multiple modes making it better than the other products presented.
Nonetheless, Ecobee addresses a diverse compatibility in OS and voice control but it certainly lacks other features. It’s sensors also needs to be improved.
Then, how about design and durability?
We say Nest 3 again. The design and construction of the device are well-engineered with the smallest volume among the other brands presented but still yet, quite heavy. Its interface is very functional with a touch-sensitive screen.
Probably, second on the list is Honeywell Lyric’s Round. The design is classy yet not as intuitive and well-constructed as Nest 3.
Who has the best app?
We say again Nest 3. The app has many features and has a reliable interface. Though, Ecobee comes close to it.
Lastly, the price?
Basically, Honeywell’s product is the cheapest price than all other devices listed here.
P.S: If you’re searching for the best sprinkler controller to control the weather for plant watering, then check out this page.